Claim A Gift vs Amazon Wish List and Birthday Gift List
Amazon lists are the easiest option if everything you want is sold on Amazon: guests buy in one click and items are marked as purchased automatically. Claim A Gift is better when your wishes come from different shops, include experiences or handmade items, or when guests shouldn't need an Amazon account. Claim A Gift lists can still include Amazon products.
At a glance
| Claim A Gift | Amazon Wish List / Birthday Gift List | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Account needed to create | No (optional) | Yes (Amazon account) |
| Guests need an account | No, just a name | Buying through the list happens on Amazon, so guests use an Amazon account |
| Gifts from any store | Yes | Amazon only (reportedly since the Amazon Assistant extension was retired in 2023) |
| Custom items (experiences, handmade) | Yes | Limited ("ideas") |
| Duplicate prevention | Guests reserve, and others see it live | Items bought from the list are marked as purchased automatically; purchases made outside the list aren't |
| Group gifts | Yes, any amount, no fees | On Amazon Baby and Wedding Registries (paid as Amazon gift card balance) |
| Thank-you list | Names revealed after the event | Yes, Amazon keeps a list of who bought what |
| Languages | English, German | Depends on the Amazon store |
Where Amazon is stronger
- One-click buying and fast delivery, with payment and shipping handled by Amazon.
- Automatic "purchased" status when guests buy through the list.
- Familiarity. Many guests already have an Amazon account.
Where Claim A Gift is stronger
- Any shop. Local toy stores, Etsy, IKEA, a bookshop, a concert ticket or "swimming lessons" can all go on one list.
- No Amazon account needed for you or your guests.
- Group gifts for any occasion, including birthdays and Christmas, with guests choosing their amount.
- One list for mixed shops, so you don't have to keep an Amazon list plus notes for everything else.
You can still add Amazon products to a Claim A Gift list. Guests click through to Amazon to buy.
Which should you choose?
| If you… | Choose |
|---|---|
| want everything from Amazon with one-click checkout | Amazon |
| want gifts from several shops or experiences | Claim A Gift |
| have guests without an Amazon account | Claim A Gift |
| want group gifts for a birthday | Claim A Gift |
FAQ
Can I add items from other websites to an Amazon wish list?
New additions must be products sold on Amazon. The browser extension that used to allow adding items from other sites was reportedly discontinued in 2023.
Do gift givers need an Amazon account?
Purchases from an Amazon list go through Amazon checkout, so buyers use an Amazon account.
Does Amazon mark items as bought?
Yes, if the guest adds the item to the cart from the list page. If they buy it elsewhere or from the normal product page, it isn't marked.
Can I put Amazon products on a Claim A Gift list?
Yes. Paste the Amazon link like any other product.
Facts checked on 30 September 2026 using Amazon Customer Service pages and the Amazon Birthday Gift List page. Claim A Gift may earn a commission from Amazon links (see the footer).
Create a list