Claim A Gift vs MyRegistry
MyRegistry is a long-established universal registry with cash gift funds and retailer integrations, popular for weddings and baby registries. Claim A Gift is a lighter, account-free list for any event, with group gifts where no money passes through the platform, so there are no fees.
At a glance
| Claim A Gift | MyRegistry | |
|---|---|---|
| Price for list owner | Free | Free |
| Account needed to create | No (optional) | Yes (members log in) |
| Guests need an account | No | No |
| Gifts from any store | Yes | Yes |
| Cash funds | No (group gifts are settled between guests) | Yes |
| Fees on cash gifts | None (no money through us) | Handling fees on cash gift funds (e.g. $3.95–$6.95 per contribution on PayPal-based funds; GoFundMe fees on newer funds) |
| Group gifts | Yes, any amount, remaining total shown | Offered (MyRegistry's 2026 guide describes group gifting on any item) |
| Best for | Birthdays, Christmas, small showers, one-off events | Weddings and baby registries with cash funds |
| Languages | English, German | Multiple |
Where MyRegistry is stronger
- Cash funds with online payment: honeymoon funds, house funds and card payments.
- Retailer integrations and a long track record, especially for weddings.
- Full registry features such as registry search.
Where Claim A Gift is stronger
- No account and no setup for small events. The list is ready in minutes.
- No fees. Group gifts are pledged in the list and paid between guests, so nothing is deducted.
- Everyday occasions. A child's birthday or a family Christmas doesn't need a full wedding-registry system.
- German interface.
Which should you choose?
| If you… | Choose |
|---|---|
| want guests to pay cash gifts online by card | MyRegistry |
| are planning a large wedding registry | MyRegistry, or Claim A Gift for a simpler setup |
| need a list for a birthday, Christmas or small shower | Claim A Gift |
| want no fees at all | Claim A Gift |
FAQ
Does MyRegistry charge fees?
MyRegistry doesn't charge list owners. Guests pay handling fees when sending money to cash gift funds. The exact fee depends on the fund type.
Do guests need a MyRegistry account?
No. MyRegistry's terms say no login is required for guests, though a registry may be password-protected.
How do group gifts work on Claim A Gift?
You set the gift's value. Each guest enters the amount they want to give, and the list shows what's left. The money is settled between guests, usually by paying the person who buys the gift.
Facts checked on 30 September 2026 using MyRegistry's terms and help centre. If something has changed, let us know.
Create a list